Academic Discussion · Basic
Sample 1: This is an online introductory nutrition course.
Professor Okafor asks
Our campus is redesigning its main cafeteria next year. Some students want more fast, familiar meals like burgers and fries, while others want more fresh salads and vegetable dishes. In your opinion, what kind of food should the cafeteria focus on, and why?
Diego: The cafeteria should focus on fast, familiar meals. Between classes I only have twenty minutes, and I want food I can grab quickly without waiting in a long line. Comfort food also helps me feel less stressed during busy weeks.
Priya: I think fresh salads and vegetables should come first. Most students already eat snacks and fast food on their own, so the cafeteria should give us the healthy options we rarely cook for ourselves. Good nutrition also helps us concentrate in afternoon classes.
Model answer
I agree with Priya that healthy food matters, but I would suggest the cafeteria make fresh meals fast rather than choosing one side. If salads are pre-packed and ready at a self-service fridge, a student can grab a healthy lunch in the same twenty minutes Diego described. For example, my old school set out boxed salads and cut fruit near the exit, and even busy students picked them up because no line was involved. This solves both problems: the food is nutritious, but it is also quick. So instead of deciding between speed and health, I think the real goal should be making the healthy choice the easy, fast choice.
Why it works. A band 5 takes a clear position, builds a claim-why-example chain, and adds the fresh 'make healthy food fast' idea neither classmate raised.
Academic Discussion · Intermediate
Sample 2: Introduction to Higher Education Policy
Professor Delgado asks
Many universities are debating whether lectures should be mandatory. Some argue that required attendance keeps students engaged and on track, while others feel adults should decide for themselves how they learn best. In your opinion, should attending lectures be mandatory for university students? Why or why not?
Mariam: I think attendance should be mandatory. When students are required to show up, they stay connected to the material and do not fall behind. Without that structure, it is too easy to skip and then struggle at exam time.
Tomas: I disagree. University students are adults, and forcing them to sit in a room does not guarantee learning. Some people absorb far more by reading the slides at their own pace at home, so attendance rules just punish independent learners.
Model answer
I understand Tomas's point that adults should manage their own time, but I side with Mariam that attendance should generally be required. My reasoning is that regular classroom contact builds accountability: when students know they must appear, they prepare beforehand, which deepens their understanding instead of cramming later. In my first-year biology course, the required sessions forced me to review notes weekly, and my exam scores clearly reflected that steady effort. One point neither of them raised is that attendance also creates community; discussing ideas with peers often clarifies what a reading alone cannot. That said, I would favor a reasonable limit on excused absences so the policy supports learning rather than simply penalizing people.
Why it works. A band-5 response states a clear position, develops one claim with a specific example (biology course), introduces a new idea (classroom community), engages a classmate by name, and uses varied grammar such as concession clauses and conditionals.
Academic Discussion · Advanced
Sample 3: Higher Education Policy
Professor Ellison asks
Many universities evaluate faculty primarily on research output, yet students are the ones paying tuition and sitting in classrooms. Some argue that rewarding research attracts talent and keeps knowledge current, while others say it quietly pushes teaching to the margins. If an institution had to tilt its incentives one way, which should it favor, and what would be lost in the bargain?
Daniela: I'd tilt toward research. A professor who is actively publishing brings unsettled, cutting-edge questions into the room rather than recycling a decade-old syllabus. Students absorb how knowledge is actually built, which is worth more than polished lecture delivery.
Marcus: I disagree, because most undergraduates will never enter a lab. They need instructors who can explain difficult material patiently and respond to confusion. Rewarding only research produces brilliant people who resent the hours they spend teaching, and students feel that resentment.
Model answer
I lean toward Marcus's position, though I'd accept that a pure teaching focus has real costs. The trade-off worth naming is that incentives shape attention: faculty rationally invest where promotion is decided, so a research-only reward structure doesn't merely neglect teaching, it actively trains professors to view it as a tax. Consider the common result, a star researcher assigning a graduate student to run discussion sections while they vanish into the lab. One qualification, however, is that the two aren't truly separable at the graduate level, where mentorship and research are the same activity. My proposal is therefore to decouple the incentives by career stage, protecting teaching for undergraduates while rewarding discovery for doctoral supervision. Daniela is right that live inquiry energizes a classroom, but energy without pedagogical skill leaves confused students admiring a performance they cannot follow.
Why it works. Band 5 needs a clear stance that engages a classmate by name, names the specific trade-off (incentives redirect attention), develops one causal chain to a concrete consequence, and adds a genuinely new idea (decoupling incentives by career stage). Language should be precise and varied.