Writing · Academic Discussion · Video lesson

Joining the Conversation

Video lessonLesson 4 of 7Intermediate20 min
In this lesson you'll learn

In this lesson you'll learn

Name a classmate, agree or disagree with their point, and then add a reason, perspective or question that nobody has given yet.

  • Name a classmate and refer to their idea, for example "While Sara makes a good point about…".
  • Agree, partly agree or disagree clearly, with phrases such as "I agree with Omar that…, but…" and "Unlike Omar, I believe…".
  • Add a new reason, perspective or question that neither classmate gave, and never just repeat their points.

Joining the Conversation

Video lessonAcademic Discussion · Lesson 4 of 7 · Intermediate · 20 min

Joining the Conversation

Name a classmate, agree or disagree with their point, and then add a reason, perspective or question that nobody has given yet.

Lesson 4 of 7 · Intermediate · No timer
Step 1 of 7: Quick check

Helps to do first: Reason, Explanation, Example. You can still continue.

Lesson 4 of 7 · Intermediate

Joining the Conversation

Name a classmate, agree or disagree with their point, and then add a reason, perspective or question that nobody has given yet.

In this lesson you'll learn

  • Name a classmate and refer to their idea, for example "While Sara makes a good point about…".
  • Agree, partly agree or disagree clearly, with phrases such as "I agree with Omar that…, but…" and "Unlike Omar, I believe…".
  • Add a new reason, perspective or question that neither classmate gave, and never just repeat their points.

Quick check

4 sentences · No timer · Guessing is fine

2 texts · answer both before you save

Read the discussion board

Homework for young children

Professor Khan: Many primary schools are now giving young children less homework. Some parents are pleased, but others are worried. Do you think young children should get homework every day? Why or why not? Sara: Yes, I think daily homework is important. It helps children practise what they learned in class, so they remember it better. Omar: I disagree. Children are already tired after six hours at school. They need time to play and rest, or they may start to dislike learning.

Question 1 of 5

Which opening names a classmate and responds to their point?

Question 2 of 5

Which sentence only repeats a classmate's point?

Question 3 of 5

You agree with Sara. Which sentence adds a reason that neither classmate gave?

Quick check · 4 sentences · No timer · Guessing is fine

Writing · Write for an Academic Discussion · Video lesson

From the video: Joining the Conversation

“Joining the Conversation” is lesson 4 of 7 for the Write for an Academic Discussion task in our free TOEFL iBT Writing lessons. It starts with a short video (about 3 minutes), then examples and practice questions.

Name a classmate, agree or disagree with their point, and then add a reason, perspective or question that nobody has given yet.

By the end of the lesson, you should be able to name a classmate and refer to their idea, for example "While Sara makes a good point about…", and agree, partly agree or disagree clearly, with phrases such as "I agree with Omar that…, but…" and "Unlike Omar, I believe…".

Key points

  1. Two classmates have already posted, and a strong post joins their conversation.
  2. A good opening names Sara, points to her idea about sleep, and then responds to it.
  3. You can partly agree: I agree with Omar, but online classes are hard for young children.
  4. A later start could be hard for parents who must leave for work early, because they would have no one to take their children to school.
  5. The first two options say the same thing as Omar in different words.
  6. Cost is a perspective that neither classmate gave, so it moves the discussion forward.
  7. Read each board, find each classmate's reason, and look for the idea that is missing.

Worked examples

Example 1

You want to disagree with Rahul. Which opening names him and responds to his point?

In the text
“When people work from home, they feel lonely”
Answer
Unlike Rahul, I believe video calls can keep colleagues close.
Why
"Unlike Rahul, I believe…" names him and answers his worry about feeling lonely with a different view. Rahul says people "feel lonely". "Unlike Rahul, I believe video calls can keep colleagues close" names him and disagrees with that point.

Example 2

Which sentence would only repeat Aisha's point?

In the text
“They save time and money because they do not need to travel to the office every day.”
Answer
Employees save time and money because they do not travel to work.
Why
Saving time and money on travel is exactly Aisha's reason, so this sentence adds nothing. Aisha already said employees "save time and money because they do not need to travel". The sentence says the same thing in slightly different words.
Video transcript454 words · about 3 min

Hello, I'm Professor Reed. In the discussion task, you are not writing alone. Two classmates have already posted, and a strong post joins their conversation. Today you will learn three moves: name a classmate, agree or disagree, and then add something new.

Here are the three moves in order. First, name a classmate, so the reader knows who you are answering. Second, respond to their point: agree, partly agree or disagree. Third, add something new, such as a reason, an example or a question that nobody has given yet.

Let's practise. The professor asks about school times, and Sara answers. Which opening joins the conversation best? Think for a moment. A good opening names Sara, points to her idea about sleep, and then responds to it. Only saying what Sara said is not enough. The answer is the second one.

Next, respond. You have three choices. You can agree: I agree with Omar that online classes save time. You can partly agree: I agree with Omar, but online classes are hard for young children. Or you can disagree: Unlike Omar, I believe students learn more in a real classroom. All three are fine, so choose your real opinion.

Now watch me write the start of a post. First, I name Sara and her idea: While Sara makes a good point about sleep. Then I give my view, and I add something new that nobody has said yet. A later start could be hard for parents who must leave for work early, because they would have no one to take their children to school.

Here is a common trap. Omar says online classes save travel time, and you agree with him. Which sentence adds something new? Think for a moment. The first two options say the same thing as Omar in different words. That is repeating, not adding. Watching a recorded class again is a new reason. The answer is the third one.

One more. Lina and Karim give two different reasons. Which idea is new to this discussion? Think for a moment. Health and hot weather are already on the board, so three options repeat them. Cost is a perspective that neither classmate gave, so it moves the discussion forward. The answer is the first one.

Before you finish, check your post with three questions. Did I name a classmate? Did I agree, partly agree or disagree? And did I add an idea that nobody gave? If the answer to the last question is no, change one sentence until it says something new.

Now it's your turn. Read each board, find each classmate's reason, and look for the idea that is missing. Try the guided questions, and use a hint if you need one.

Lesson notes. Name a classmate, agree or disagree with their point, and then add a reason, perspective or question that nobody has given yet.

Name a classmate

Your post is part of a conversation, so show who you are answering. Use a classmate's name and their idea: "While Sara makes a good point about practice, I think…" or "I agree with Omar that…". Writing only "some students think" does not join the conversation.

Agree, partly agree or disagree

You can agree ("I agree with Omar that…"), partly agree ("I agree with Omar that…, but…") or disagree ("Unlike Omar, I believe…"). All three are fine. Choose the one that matches your real opinion, and say it clearly. Retelling a classmate's post is not a response.

Add something new, don't repeat

After you respond, add an idea that is not on the board yet: a new reason, a new point of view, an example from your life or a question. If a classmate already said it, even in different words, it does not move the discussion forward. Check each sentence against both posts.

Four ways to join in

Name a classmateShow who you are answering. Use a classmate's name and their idea, not "some people think".
Agree or disagreeAfter the name, say clearly whether you agree, partly agree or disagree. Only retelling a classmate's post is not a response.
Add something newFind the idea that is missing from the board. A new reason, a new point of view or a question moves the discussion forward.
Don't repeatIf a classmate already said it, even in different words, it does not count as your idea. Check each sentence against the board.

Common mistakes

  • Writing "some people think" instead of naming a classmate and their idea.
  • Naming a classmate but only retelling their post, without saying whether you agree.
  • Repeating a classmate's reason in different words and treating it as a new idea.
  • Agreeing with both classmates, so the post has no clear position.

Lessons in this task

Practise Academic Discussion · All Writing lessons