Writing · Academic Discussion · Video lesson

Reading the Discussion Board

Video lessonLesson 1 of 7Basic20 min
In this lesson you'll learn

In this lesson you'll learn

Before you write, find the professor's exact question, each classmate's position and reason, and what your post must do.

  • Find the professor's exact question and notice its shape: yes or no, which option, or how and why.
  • Note each classmate's position and the reason that supports it.
  • Know what your post must do: express and support your opinion in your own words, with at least 100 words in 10 minutes.

Reading the Discussion Board

Video lessonAcademic Discussion · Lesson 1 of 7 · Basic · 20 min

Reading the Discussion Board

Before you write, find the professor's exact question, each classmate's position and reason, and what your post must do.

Lesson 1 of 7 · Basic · No timer
Step 1 of 7: Quick check

Lesson 1 of 7 · Basic

Reading the Discussion Board

Before you write, find the professor's exact question, each classmate's position and reason, and what your post must do.

In this lesson you'll learn

  • Find the professor's exact question and notice its shape: yes or no, which option, or how and why.
  • Note each classmate's position and the reason that supports it.
  • Know what your post must do: express and support your opinion in your own words, with at least 100 words in 10 minutes.

Quick check

4 sentences · No timer · Guessing is fine

2 texts · answer both before you save

Read the discussion board

Attending lectures

Professor Khan: Many universities now record their lectures and put them online. Some teachers say this means students no longer need to come to class. Should universities make attendance at lectures compulsory? Why or why not? Sara: Yes, I think attendance should be required. When I am in the room, I can ask the teacher a question at once, and I remember much more of the lesson. Omar: I disagree. Many students have part-time jobs or long journeys to campus. Recorded lectures let them study at a time that works for them, so attendance should be their own choice.

Question 1 of 5

What exactly is Professor Khan asking?

Question 2 of 5

What is Omar's position?

Question 3 of 5

What reason does Sara give for her view?

Quick check · 4 sentences · No timer · Guessing is fine

Writing · Write for an Academic Discussion · Video lesson

From the video: Reading the Discussion Board

“Reading the Discussion Board” is lesson 1 of 7 for the Write for an Academic Discussion task in our free TOEFL iBT Writing lessons. It starts with a short video (about 3 minutes), then examples and practice questions.

Before you write, find the professor's exact question, each classmate's position and reason, and what your post must do.

By the end of the lesson, you should be able to find the professor's exact question and notice its shape: yes or no, which option, or how and why, and note each classmate's position and the reason that supports it.

Key points

  1. Before you write a single word, you need to read the board carefully.
  2. Your post comes last, so you are the third student in the conversation.
  3. Read to the end of the professor's post and find the question mark.
  4. Professor questions come in a few common shapes.
  5. Notice the shape, because your first sentence must answer that exact question.
  6. Positions are not always a simple yes or no.
  7. Make a contribution to the discussion in your own words, so do not copy sentences from the board.

Worked examples

Example 1

What kind of question does Professor Mensah ask?

In the text
“Which approach do you think is better for students: banning phones in class or allowing them?”
Answer
A question asking which of two approaches is better
Why
The question starts with "Which approach" and names two choices: banning phones or allowing them. "Which approach do you think is better" asks you to choose one of two options, so your post must pick banning or allowing.

Example 2

What is Priya's position?

In the text
“I prefer a ban.”
Answer
Phones should be banned during lessons.
Why
Priya says "I prefer a ban" in her first sentence. Checking a word is part of her reason, not her position. Her position comes first: "I prefer a ban." The rest of her post gives the reason: phones distract her.
Video transcript393 words · about 3 min

Hello, I'm Professor Reed. In the academic discussion task, you join an online class discussion. Before you write a single word, you need to read the board carefully. Today you will learn what to look for: the exact question, each classmate's position and reason, and what your own post must do.

The board has three parts. First, the professor gives some background and then asks a question. Next, two classmates reply. They usually disagree, and each one gives a reason. Your post comes last, so you are the third student in the conversation.

The background is not the question. Read to the end of the professor's post and find the question mark. What exactly does the professor ask? Think for a moment. The first sentences only give background. The real question comes at the end, and it asks which of two choices is better. The answer is the third one.

Professor questions come in a few common shapes. Some are yes or no questions, such as: should schools ban phones? Some ask which option is better. Others ask how or why something happens. Notice the shape, because your first sentence must answer that exact question.

Now look at the two classmates. For each one, find two things: the position, yes or no, and the reason that supports it. What is Omar's reason? Think for a moment. Sara says yes, and her reason is making friends faster. Omar says no, and his reason is money, because rooms in town are cheaper. The answer is the second one.

Positions are not always a simple yes or no. Sometimes a classmate agrees only in part. What is Layla's position? Think for a moment. Layla likes the idea, but then she adds a limit. She says yes, but only for the city centre. The answer is the second one.

Finally, read the instructions. They ask for three things. Express and support your opinion. Make a contribution to the discussion in your own words, so do not copy sentences from the board. And write at least one hundred words. You have ten minutes for all of this.

Now it's your turn. For every board, ask yourself three questions. What exactly is the question? What does each classmate think, and why? And what must my post do? Try the guided questions, and use a hint if you need one.

Lesson notes. Before you write, find the professor's exact question, each classmate's position and reason, and what your post must do.

Find the exact question

The professor's post starts with background. The question usually comes at the end, with a question mark. Notice its shape: a yes or no question (Should…? Do you think…?), a which-option question (Which is better: A or B?) or a how or why question. Your post must answer that exact question, not just the general topic.

Note each position and reason

Two classmates reply, and they usually disagree. For each one, find two things: the position (yes, no, one of the options, or a careful view such as "yes, but only in the city centre") and the reason that supports it. A story, such as a cousin's experience, supports the reason. It is not the reason itself.

Know what your post must do

The instructions ask you to express and support your opinion and to make a contribution to the discussion in your own words, so do not copy sentences from the board. An effective response will contain at least 100 words, and you have 10 minutes. Spend about a minute reading the board before you plan.

Four things to find on the board

The exact questionThe question usually comes last. Find it, and notice what kind of answer it needs.
Their positionsEach classmate's first sentence usually shows their view. Watch for careful views with words like but, mostly or only.
Their reasonsThe reason is why they hold their view. A story or example supports the reason, but it is not the reason itself.
What you must doGive your own opinion, support it, add to the discussion without copying the board, and write at least 100 words.

Common mistakes

  • Answering the background topic instead of the professor's exact question.
  • Mixing up the two classmates, or thinking an example is the reason.
  • Missing a careful position such as "yes, but only in the city centre" and reading it as a simple yes.
  • Copying sentences from the board, or writing fewer than 100 words.

Lessons in this task

Practise Academic Discussion · All Writing lessons